I’ve put off upgrading my trusty Media Center 2005 box now for quite a while for a variety of reasons. However, since V2 extenders are imminent, and because I snagged some super-cheap copies of Vista Ultimate from the Microsoft Store, I decided now was the time to try Vista Media Center for a while.

(One of the nice things about Windows Home Server is that you can do things like this, safe in the knowledge your old install is only a few clicks away :) .

Unfortunately my experiences so far have been largely negative.

The first problem was more of an inconvenience. When upgrading from MCE2005 some Media Center settings are preserved but others, such as the TV setup, are not. This is a little frustrating as it couldn’t have been that hard to implement, and it takes a good 40 minutes edit the channel list to reflect which of your providers ~700 channels you both subscribe to and want to watch. The method of making this selection has not improved since MCE2005 either and is still slow and cumbersome.

In terms of hardware I only came across one problem; the Microsoft IR receiver/blaster that controls our cable boxes would only emit a signal from one bud. After a couple of reboots I ended up uninstalling it via device manager and restarting, whereupon it was recognized as a new device and began working correctly.

The other problems I’m seeing are all performance based.

Under Vista, the Media Center UI frequently becomes laggy and often hangs/pauses for a few seconds. For example if I press Guide on the remote while watching TV there’s a delay of ~5 seconds before it appears. Other areas of the UI can become equally unresponsive at times, which leads to multiple button presses and general frustration.

Another problem is that VMCE’s handling of video thumbnails seems to be very poorly implemented. Our videos are stored on our Windows Home Server, with shortcuts placed in the "Videos" folder on the Media Center, and browsing these folders from within MCE results in the UI hanging for considerable amounts of time.

For example when I opened the folder containing Heroes Season 1, the UI hung for around five minutes while thumbnails were generated for all of the files. This problem never occurred in MCE, nor does it while using Explorer in Vista, so it’s definitely something within the Media Center UI. As far as I can tell the UI spawns a copy of Media Player in the background to generate the thumbnails, but does so in a very unfriendly way. The episodes themselves stream fine (although there’s still no way to fast-forward xvid files) so it’s not a bandwidth issue.

Speaking of thumbnails, I have very mixed feelings over the "Wall of thumbnails" that Vista Media Center uses for the UI in the Music/Video sections. While it looks fantastic it sacrifices usability to do so. The only way to see the title of a video/album is to select it, so although the UI fits more items on each "page" than MCE2005 it can take longer to find the file you’re after. There’s an alternative "List" view which shows the content as a list of names, but you then loose the thumbnail image and looks boring (strangely the ‘list’ option in Recorded TV includes a mini thumbnail, but not so in Music/Videos).

On the flip-side the new UI looks fantastic and is generally better organized than MCE2005, which now looks very dated.

I’d really like to like VMCE but at the moment the experience is far below my MCE2005 install. I’m going to push on with it for a while longer and see what I can do to improve the performance issues, but so far I’m rather underwhelmed :(